Hamas October 7 massacre was God stopping an Israeli civil war - opinion

Whenever I find myself under pressure, such as in these days, living in Israel, with grandsons serving in the IDF in Gaza, I try to find a moment of tranquility and inner peace. In this madhouse, it is important to keep my cool. But where shall I find it? 

Strangely enough, it is in the war and its aftermath where I find my serenity. 

I have a feeling that this war has an ontological aspect. Without any claim to prophecy, I cannot escape the feeling that what is happening at this moment is not just another Israeli-Palestinian war but something radically different. 

After the terrible internal fights that tore apart the Israeli nation, in which Jews were on the verge of going to war against each other, nearly destroying the State of Israel, it is as if a divine voice appeared and said: “Enough! This far and no further! There will not be a civil war in Israel. I will not allow it. I will force your hand and compel you to make peace among yourselves as you have never seen before. If you cannot do it yourselves, I will do it for you. Until you get the message. Until you wake up and stop your meaningless fights and get back to yourselves. Who do you think you are? You want to destroy the State of Israel, leaving Jews around the world totally forsaken with nowhere to go? I will not stand for it. I will look you in the face and ask you, ‘What are you doing?’ And you will bow your heads and say, ‘How did we ever get so low and act so irresponsibly?’”

The foundations are shaken

Zionism – and its promise that the State of Israel will be a secure haven for any Jew and a guarantee of liberty for its citizens – has been badly undermined. It has been shaken and trembles on its foundations. 

The government, overconfident and overflowing with arrogance, is nearly paralyzed and does not know what to do next. 

Convinced that it was all-powerful, indestructible, and would always be victorious, the Israeli army received a major blow when it could not even defend Israel’s citizens. Right under its eyes, a small Holocaust took place, not in a foreign country but in the Holy Land itself! Women were raped, children and babies burned alive, and hundreds taken captive. And all that under the slogan “Never again!”

Were it not so tragic, it would be pathetic.

A light from the darkness

But just at the moment when all looked black, an almost open miracle took place. 

As if from the valley of the dead, Israel rose up, and in a matter of a moment the nation healed itself. Like a lion from cover, the nation showed its true face. Out of nowhere, people who had come to believe they were archenemies embraced one another. 

Massive numbers of soldiers reported to recruiting stations and military outposts. Instead of waiting to be conscripted, they arrived in multitudes of their own free will. Haredi men volunteered, were quickly trained, and sent off to wherever they were needed.

Tzitziyot, prayer shawls, and tefillin were distributed, and many secular soldiers donned them, dressed in religious garb for the first time.

The nation came together, kissed each other, danced together, religious and nonreligious prayed together, and all realized that they are one united family. They collected enormous sums of money for the evacuees and touched a level of unity that was unheard of. They amassed necessities of every kind at such a rapid rate that those who received them did not know how to distribute them quickly enough. 

World Jewry – often ambivalent in its attitude toward Israel – suddenly realized that the people in Israel are not just human beings on the other side of the ocean but brothers in arms. Family.

All this is unprecedented.

Birth pangs of a new nation

This outpouring of love, and the disaster that preceded it, seem to have given birth to a new Israel. A transformation has taken place. We are still in the wake of its first contractions. Will the baby be healthy? Will this unity prevail when the war is over? We do not yet know. But what is for sure is that a new kind of offspring will appear. It took 75 years for it to develop in the womb of this nation, but it is now coming. 

In the beginning, it may be insecure. It will need to learn how to breathe, to crawl and to walk, and grow. The physicians will have to be careful so as to deliver the baby properly. They may disagree on what procedures to use, but they should know that the people of Israel will not allow them to fail.

This nation is unlike all other nations. What has become clear is that even the most secular Jew realizes that he/she has a uniquely Jewish soul, which will not surrender when challenged. 

We know that there is a high cost to be paid to be a Jew, but we also know that there is no greater privilege. 

We know that we must be exceptional in order to live in a world that is neither propitious for – nor sympathetic to – our survival. 

We know that the Jewish people is indispensable, and against all predictions will not just survive but succeed.

We know that to be a Jew, one must be holy.

There has never been a greater need for Judaism’s message than in our time.

It is not good enough to just be a “good human being” or to be a “good Jew at heart.” If a Jew is no more than human, then he/she is less than human because to be Jewish means to exceed what is expected. To be a Jew means to surpass normalcy and climb to the top of the mountain. 

All of Jewish history proves that Jews are a nation “dwelling apart and not to be reckoned among the nations” (Numbers 23:9).

We Jews must be moral and religious pioneers as were our ancestors for nearly 4,000 years. 

The future of all of mankind depends on our commitment to be holy and to illuminate the light of humanity’s future vision. 

EVEN IF I were an atheist, I would not be able to deny that something exceptional is taking place. We are standing on the brink of a new world. 

Jews who does not “re-Jew” themselves at this hour – who continue on their way as if just another war is taking place and live as they did before – will forever regret that they may have forfeited the greatest moment in their lifetime.

We have never been the same since the day on which the voice of God overwhelmed us at Sinai. So it is now. We will never be the same since the message of unity has emerged from this war in a seemingly supernatural way. At this hour, all of the future of our people is entrusted in our hands. We will either forfeit it or enrich it. 

Let the divine voice not embarrass us again and force us even more on our knees. We cannot afford it. Our children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren will never forgive us. 

We stand at a crossroads, and it seems that something unprecedented is happening. It is for all the world to watch.

Today many of the world’s citizens hate us for this war. Tomorrow they will realize that we fought their war, and we saved them.

I do not know whether we will ever forgive our enemies for killing our children, but what I do know for sure is that we will never forgive them for forcing us to kill their children, said Golda Meir. We Jews do not rejoice in victories. For us, a war won is a victory lost. 

The Jews are God’s stake in human history. I am witness to a supreme moment in that history. 

That is my tranquility in this hour of war. 

It is Abraham Joshua Heschel who said: “The gravest sin for a Jew is to forget what he represents.” Let us live up to his words. We are made to be a holy people, and we shall not betray our pledge. ■

The writer is the dean of the David Cardozo Academy in Jerusalem. He is the author of many books, including the bestseller Jewish Law as Rebellion. Find his weekly essays at www.cardozoacademy.org