menu-control
The Jerusalem Post

ICJ’s selective justice: How bias skews Rafah ruling against Israel - comment

 
British jurist Malcolm Shaw and Yaron Wax look on at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), during a ruling on South Africa's request to order a halt to Israel's Rafah offensive in Gaza as part of a larger case brought before the Hague-based court by South Africa accusing Israel of genocide, in T (photo credit: JOHANNA GERON/REUTERS)
British jurist Malcolm Shaw and Yaron Wax look on at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), during a ruling on South Africa's request to order a halt to Israel's Rafah offensive in Gaza as part of a larger case brought before the Hague-based court by South Africa accusing Israel of genocide, in T
(photo credit: JOHANNA GERON/REUTERS)

The court's reluctance to acknowledge Israel's self-defense claims stands in sharp contrast to its handling of previous cases, like that of Bosnia and Herzegovina's case against Serbia.

The Irish deputy premier complained that Israel’s reprimand of the Irish ambassador over Ireland’s decision to recognize Palestinian statehood was “completely unacceptable,” the Evening Standard reported on Saturday.

Ambassador Sonya McGuinness was reproved by Israel’s Foreign Ministry after Ireland made the decision to formally recognize Palestinian statehood, and, as the meeting continued, was shown footage of Hamas’s October 7 attack.

Irish Deputy Premier Micheál Martin complained on Friday, saying, “I find that totally unacceptable and no way to treat diplomats... [it] is outside the norm by which diplomats are treated in any country.”

Martin continued: “Diplomatic channels are very important in terms of maintaining contact with people explaining governments’ respective positions.

Advertisement

“Sonya McGuinness is an outstanding ambassador, and we have consistently condemned the Hamas attack on October 7,” he stressed.

 Israeli President Isaac Herzog is seen receiving the new Irish ambassador, at the President's Residence, on September 19, 2023. (credit: HAIM ZACH/GPO)
Israeli President Isaac Herzog is seen receiving the new Irish ambassador, at the President's Residence, on September 19, 2023. (credit: HAIM ZACH/GPO)

Martin expressed having a particular issue with McGuinness being shown the footage in front of members of the Israeli media, adding that it was something Ireland had not “witnessed before in other countries or jurisdictions.”

“Most people would accept internationally that that’s not within the parameters of acceptable norms in terms of how people engage with diplomats,” he explained. “I will communicate directly – in writing if necessary – to the Israeli foreign minister because our speeches on recognition of Palestine were balanced.”

“In terms of my own contribution,” he added, “It was very clear in terms of our rejection of any mono-ethnic approach to the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.”


Stay updated with the latest news!

Subscribe to The Jerusalem Post Newsletter


Katz condemns Ireland, Spain and Norway

Foreign Minister Israel Katz charged that Ireland, alongside Spain and Norway, had “rewarded terrorism” after they recognized a Palestinian state.

Advertisement

Katz said ambassadors from the three countries were shown the footage as part of a “severe démarche.”

×
Email:
×
Email: